Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

They provide the matlab code and source inputs for their experiments, you could attempt to verify their results if you don't believe the video.


Should we believe videos and articles?

I think we should demand more. We are being presented science right? We should be able to recognise that this article and the videos, etc are just presenting a claim. They are not providing any evidence. This is just a story.


I'm not sure what you're asking, the tools are there for you to replicate their experiment.


I'm saying, if someone writes an article and it is published, should we believe it?

You're saying that I should use tools to replicate the experiment. Great - this is what we should do before we accept something as true. Otherwise, we are in the realms of 'belief'.

So, do you believe this story? And did you do due diligence, and confirm with the tools that it is true? Or did you skip that bit and believe it despite the fact that NO evidence is presented at all? Be honest when you answer please!

Stepping back a bit, I'm not saying anything so drastic. I certainly don't see why I'm being downvoted. I'm really talking about applying the scientific method personally. I'm saying don't accept articles, videos by default, without even critically reading what is being presented. I really think its pretty obvious stuff, tbh!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: